I’ve been wearing Banana Republic jeans for a long time. Not only because I love them, which I do, but because I know exactly what I’m getting when I order them online.
I’ve wanted to branch out to other jean brands for a while to see what I’ve been missing, but the difference in fit was a high barrier of entry for shopping online. I went to the Levi’s store to do the heavy lifting for all of us, and I hope that the findings this brief Levi’s style comparison help in your decision-making. The timing worked out too, because there’s currently a 25% off sale styles at Levi’s website. Use the promo code 25SUMMER to get the deal.
The Current Champ:
I wear a 31×32 in the Banana Republic Slim Vintage Wash Jean. These jeans fit the butt well, and they are tight around the waist. On the first wear after washing, it’s a tight fit for a phone in the front pocket when I’m sitting down, but they loosen up on subsequent wears. The fit is a little long for a 32, and they taper around the ankle. This means that they bunch up on bulkier shoes, which can be frustrating if I’m not going for that look.
I buy these jeans because I know what I’m getting. They fit well and my wife likes how I look in them.
Normally (with my BR jeans) I wear a 31×32, but in the 501 Levi’s Original Fit the 32” waist was tight.
I believe that this is due to the waist riding a little low. The fit, though, was comfortable around the waist as well as on the butt. For non-slim fit jeans, the pockets were a little tight for my phone (an HTC One). Additionally, the 501 is well-known for being a button-fly jean — not my favorite feature.
The Verdict: Take a pass. They fit great and made me look good, so pretty big plusses. On the downside, the button-fly is not conducive to late nights at the bar, so I decided to take a pass and avoid the drunken fly fumble. That may not be a big deal for everyone else, but I really prefer a zipper.
I tried on a 31×32 of the Levi’s Slim Taper. I’m not sure if these jeans are high-waisted or low-crotched. If you wear them where I usually wear jeans, they made me feel like a mom in the ’90s. I guess that style is back for the ladies, but I’m not ready to buy into all of that hullabaloo. They fit tight, but there’s still room for a phone in your pocket when you sit down. Due to the high waist, they were baggy on the butt for a slender guy like myself. The jeans had a quad break on the shoe, so they must run a little longer than the other styles. With as high as they fit on my waist and as long as they were in the leg, I definitely wasn’t feeling the style. They were also loose around the waist for a 31” — odd because I had to size-up for the 501s and the 511s (reviewed below) compared to the Banana Republic size I’ve been wearing for the past couple of years.
The Verdict: Take a pass. I’m not interested in rocking high-waisted jeans that are baggy around my butt. These pants were not made for guys like me.
I tried on a 32×32 of the Levi’s Athletic Fit. They fit great around the waist. From there, though, they were baggy — baggy around my thighs and baggy around my calves.
The Verdict: I took a pass. These pants didn’t fit me well at all. They’d be great for people who have a tough time fitting their butt, thighs, and/or calves into a more traditional cut of jeans.
I had to try on two pairs of these. First, I tried on a pair of the Levi’s Slim Fit non-stretch, heavyweight denim (12 oz.) in a 31×32.
There are no pictures of these because once I got them up to my boxer briefs, I began a tucking-in operation in earnest. They were so stiff they felt starched. I got them up past my waist before I realized that there was no way that I would ever get the jean’s closing mechanism to operate.
The Verdict: I felt like Kramer.
I asked for a different pair to try on, leading me to…
The second option was a pair of Levi’s Slim Fit stretch heavyweight denim in a 32×32.
They fit like a dream, and they had plenty of room to spare due to the fabric’s stretching ability. Pizza and Mountain Dew during a long release night, here I come! They felt nearly the same as the 501s down to the knees, but then the taper kicks in so they hugged my calves more. They’re a little bit lower-waisted than the 501s, and reproduce the same butt-hugging properties of the original. The stretch in the jeans means that even though they’re a little more snug looking, they actually fit my phone better when sitting down.
The Verdict: Buy! These 511s had of the good qualities of the classic 501 jean, with stretchy fabric in a cut that’s a little more modern. The stretch fabric blend makes these jeans fit similar to my favorite Banana Republic jeans while being a little bit more forgiving when I need to move.
Thanks for reading that article. Want another? Subscribe to our email to get new content in your inbox daily. Or connect with us on Twitter to see our updates there. We're on Facebook too, but Mark's algorithm is probably going to mostly show you baby pics and idiot rants. We can't compete with that.
Want to support our site and eat better? Check out Blue Apron, a new approach to healthy cooking.